So, yeah. Hobbits. I’ve actually been contemplating them for
a while now. I've been playing LEGO Lord of the Rings on the Xbox 360, and the new Hobbit movie in December prompted me to ask on
Facebook: Bilbo or Frodo? The response was pretty much unanimously in favor of
Bilbo, with disparaging comments about Frodo to the extent that he is a weak
character who perhaps should not have been included in the book at all. I’ve
seen several places online where folks argue that Frodo is not the main
character of The Lord of the Rings, and even my own husband has voiced his
belief that Sam Gamgee is actually the hero of those stories. All of this
puzzles me, because up until a few years ago, to my knowledge, Frodo was almost
universally beloved. Like all Hobbits who feature prominently in Tolkien’s
stories, Frodo is an ordinary little fellow who was thrust unwillingly into an
extraordinary series of events. However, Frodo actually did something that no
one else did: He saved the world. I hear you critics now: “No, he didn’t! He
wanted to keep the Ring at the end! It’s only by accident that … (spoiler
removed)” I would just like to point out that Frodo kept faithfully to his
purpose through the entire story, and it was only at the last critical moment,
when faced with the unrelenting pressure of Sauron’s power expressed through
the Ring, that he wavered. It is my opinion that Frodo is the only person in all
of Middle-Earth who could have successfully carried the Ring to the fire of
Mount Doom without giving in to the temptation to claim it for his own. Which
is why the Ring came to him in the first place. Because he was the hero.
Now, on to Bilbo for a moment. Bilbo is a delightful little
Hobbit. He’s crafty, creative, can talk his way out of just about any
situation, but when talking fails, he’s handy in a fight. When compared to
Frodo, it’s not surprising that we tend to like him better. We sympathize with
Frodo, we admire Frodo, we applaud Frodo, or perhaps we criticize Frodo, but we
like Bilbo. He’d be much more fun to have a conversation with, I think. There’s
all this drama that surrounds poor Frodo. All Bilbo had to do was sneak into a
dragon’s lair and steal something. Saving the world was not on the agenda for
his adventure, so he could come home relatively unscathed. Frodo came home
broken. Bilbo’s story is fun. Frodo’s is epic, with all the triumph and tragedy
that tends to go along with epic heroes.
So, Bilbo or Frodo? Or for that matter, Sam, Merry or
Pippin? I don’t know that I could pick one if I had to. I will just say that I
love Hobbits. They are one of the most intriguing little races of people that
have ever been introduced into literature, and further proof that Tolkien was
an absolute genius.
Feel free to comment
with all your anti-Frodo feelings here. He’s not a real person. He won’t be
offended.